Evaluating the structure of research papers: A case study
Wieringa, Roel and Heerkens, Hans (2004) Evaluating the structure of research papers: A case study. In: Second International Workshop in Comparative Evaluation of Requirements Engineering, CERE 2004, 5-10 September 2004, Kyoto, Japan (pp. pp. 41-50).
|Abstract:||This paper is triggered by a concern for the methodological soundness of research papers in RE. We propose a number of criteria for methodological soundness, and apply these to a random sample of 37 submissions to the RE'03
conference. From this application, we draw a number of conclusions that we claim are valid for a larger sample than just these 37 submissions. Our major observation is that most submissions in our sample are solution-oriented:
they present a solution and illustrate it with a problem, rather than search for a solution to a given problem class; and most papers do not analyze why and when a solution works or does not work. We end with discussion of the need to improve the methodological soundness of research papers in RE.
|Item Type:||Conference or Workshop Item|
Electrical Engineering, Mathematics and Computer Science (EEMCS)
Management and Governance (SMG)
|Link to this item:||http://purl.utwente.nl/publications/64194|
|Export this item as:||BibTeX|
Daily downloads in the past month
Monthly downloads in the past 12 months
Repository Staff Only: item control page